Why the economy, not ideology, will decide the US Midterms

A year ago, the idea that the Democrats could win both the House of Representatives and the Senate in this week’s midterm election in the United States would have seemed highly improbable. Yet today, it’s the most likely outcome, according to exclusive insights from SEC Newgate’s partner business in the US headed up by leading pollster Jefrey Pollock.

In brief:

  • Democrats are favoured to win both chambers of Congress in this week’s US midterm election, according to leading US Democratic pollster Jefrey Pollock.
  • Economic dissatisfaction is driving the political shift, with voters increasingly believing Republicans are not focused on their most pressing concerns.
  • Democratic control of Congress would significantly weaken the ability of the Trump administration to advance its agenda during its final two years.

The swing towards the Democrats is not being driven by culture wars, partisan loyalties or the latest political controversy in the States.

Instead, it reflects a much simpler reality: every key indicator points to deep voter dissatisfaction with the Trump administration’s handling of the economy. Rising living costs, fuel prices and economic uncertainty have become the defining issues of the campaign, overwhelming almost every other political debate.

According to Pollock, whose firm is at the coalface of the election across 34 US jurisdictions, President Trump’s economic approval rating sits at minus 33. Among independent voters, traditionally the decisive bloc in US elections, Trump’s ratings are underwater across every major policy area.

Just as importantly, many voters believe the administration is focused on the wrong issues.

They are not seeing the Republicans prioritising voters’ top concerns – inflation, cost of living, jobs, healthcare and government corruption – and this is translating to growing frustration, including among traditionally conservative voters. The resulting perception gap is creating political vulnerability in places that, on paper, should be safely Republican.

Why this midterm election looks different

Historically, midterms are brutal for incumbent presidents. Yet the scale of Trump’s political challenge is unusual.

Pollock notes that Trump’s approval ratings are lower than those suffered by George W. Bush in 2006 or Barack Obama in 2010, both of whom presided over major Congressional losses for their parties.

Ordinarily, numbers like these would point to a political wave election.

The complication for Democrats is structural. Electoral boundary changes have reduced the number of genuinely competitive House seats, limiting how large any Democratic victory can ultimately become.

Nevertheless, Democrats appear to have two significant advantages – substantially higher levels of motivation to vote than Republicans, and stronger than expected early mail voting across several battleground states. While Republican Election Day turnout could still close the gap, the early indicators are encouraging for Democrats.

The Senate is where it gets really interesting.  To retain control, Democrats must not only defend a series of marginal seats but also win in states President Trump carried by 10 points or more in 2024.

While winning many of these races would require extraordinarily large swings, races that were once considered safely Republican are suddenly competitive even in rural heartland and the Democrats are likely to secure enough victories to win Senate control.

What happens if Democrats win?

A Democratic takeover of the House would quickly reshape Washington, with a likely acceleration of Congressional investigations into alleged corruption, conflicts of interest and administration conduct. However, the Democrats would be wise to avoid becoming consumed by impeachment efforts, which served only to re-boot the Trump campaign that led to him taking back the Presidency.

Control of the Senate would have even greater implications. Most significantly, it would allow Democrats to block future conservative judicial appointments. With speculation already circulating around the future retirement plans of several ageing Supreme Court justices, Senate control could have ramifications extending well beyond Trump’s current term.

At the same time, Pollock believes complete legislative gridlock is not inevitable. Trump’s transactional political instincts may yet create opportunities for bipartisan deals on economic issues such as prescription drug costs or other cost-of-living measures.

Beyond the immediate electoral arithmetic, perhaps the most important takeaway is what this election says about modern politics, which rings true here at home.

Despite the intense focus on cultural debates, immigration and social issues, voters appear overwhelmingly motivated by household economics and the answer to a simple question: Do they feel materially better off than they did before?

According to Pollock’s reading, millions of Americans currently believe the answer is ‘no’.

If that sentiment holds next week, it’s likely to translate to Democratic control of both chambers of Congress and a significantly weakened Trump presidency entering its final two years.

Contacts 

Contact us to find out how we can help your business navigate the shifting political landscape.

Brian Tyson, Chairman, SEC Newgate – [email protected]

Share this

Related Services

SEC Newgate’s integrated approach draws on our national team’s experience and networks to deliver a full service offering.